The Coffee Conversation

A You and a Few Guide
How to talk to the people in your life about defending democracy together — even if you've never had this kind of conversation before.
Start Here
Goal Have your first honest conversation about defending democracy with someone in your life.
Time to Read 12 minutes
What You'll Do After Invite one person for coffee this week using the scripts in this guide.
One Line You Can Use Today "I've been watching what's happening and I realized I've been keeping it to myself. Can we talk?"

Three forces are keeping you silent

Starting this conversation feels risky. That's not weakness — it's psychology. There are three specific forces working against you, and knowing their names takes away their power.

01
Pluralistic Ignorance
Everyone privately disagrees with what's happening, but nobody says so — because everyone is reading everyone else's poker face and concluding they must be the only one who's bothered. You're not.
02
Social Cost Anxiety
You worry about being labeled "political" or "dramatic." This is real. But the cost of silence compounds. Each day you don't speak, the norm of silence gets stronger. The first person pays the highest cost — and creates the most change.
03
Not Knowing What to Say
You're not an activist. You don't have a speech prepared. That's fine. You're not giving a speech. You're having coffee. What follows is exactly what that looks like.

Look for quiet discomfort

You're not looking for the loudest voice in the room. You're looking for people who show quiet discomfort — the ones who change the subject, go silent when certain topics come up, or make brief comments that hint at concern.

Start with one person. Not four. One. The first conversation is the hardest. After that, you'll know what works. The second gets easier. By the fourth, you'll have a group.

01
Open with honesty, not a pitch

Don't start with politics. Start with how you feel. Vulnerability is disarming and creates safety. You're not recruiting — you're sharing.

You
"Hey, can I be honest about something? I've been watching what's happening to our democracy — the attacks on the courts, on the press, on people's basic rights — and I realized I've been keeping it to myself because I didn't want to be 'that person.' But I think not talking about it is making it worse."
✓ Why this works

You've named the discomfort. You've admitted to the same silence they've been practicing. You've made it safe for them to agree without being the first to "go there."

02
Listen before you lead

After you open, stop talking. Give them space. They may need a moment. They may be cautious. They may surprise you with how much they've been holding in. Your job right now is to listen, not convince.

Them (likely responses)
"Oh my god, me too. I've been losing sleep over this."
"Yeah, I mean... it's definitely concerning. I try not to think about it too much."
"I don't really follow politics that closely, but some of the stuff I've seen..."

All three are openings. Enthusiastic agreement. Cautious agreement. A crack in the door. In all three cases, they've admitted to concern. That's the seed.

03
Share the research, not your opinions

This is where the 3.5% finding does its work. You're not asking them to agree with your politics. You're sharing a research finding that reframes what's possible. Facts feel safer than opinions.

You
"I found something that actually made me feel less helpless. There's this political scientist — Erica Chenoweth — who studied over 300 movements throughout history. And she found that every nonviolent movement that got 3.5% of the population involved succeeded. Every single one. No exceptions."
"And what hit me is — 3.5% of our office is like 7 people. That doesn't sound impossible."
✓ Why this works

You've shifted from feelings to evidence. You've localized the number. And you've said the magic words: "that doesn't sound impossible." You've given them permission to believe change is achievable.

04
Invite, don't recruit

There's a critical difference between recruiting someone to a cause and inviting them into a conversation. Recruitment creates obligation and resistance. Invitation creates agency and interest.

You
"I'm not trying to start a protest or anything. I just think... what if a few of us started talking openly about this? Like, not on social media, not performing it for anyone. Just us, being honest about what we're seeing and thinking about what we can actually do. Even small things."
Key phrases that work

"I'm not asking you to do anything dramatic" — lowers the perceived cost

"I think just talking honestly is the first step" — makes the ask achievable

"Even small things matter" — removes the paralysis of needing to do something big

"Would you be open to..." — invitation framing, not demand

05
End with a concrete next step

Don't let the conversation dissolve into "yeah, we should totally do something sometime." Vagueness is where good intentions go to die. End with something specific, small, and soon.

You
"Could we grab lunch Thursday? I'll share the website I found — youandafew.org — and we can figure out if there's anyone else here who might want to be part of this conversation."

That's it. You've planted a seed, established a next step, and begun to form a group. You haven't asked anyone to march. You've asked them to have lunch.

Not everyone will say yes. That's okay.

Here's how to handle common responses with grace — keeping the door open without compromising the message.

"I just try to stay out of politics."

"I totally get that. I used to feel the same way. I think what shifted for me is realizing that some of this isn't really politics anymore — it's about whether the systems that protect all of us keep working. But I respect where you are. The door's open if you change your mind."

"What can we actually do, though?"

"Honestly? The research says the first thing is just deciding not to be silent anymore. The bystander effect — where everyone freezes because they think they're alone — that's the main thing that needs to break. And it only takes one person in a room to break it. After that, there are specific things. But the first step is just this: a few people deciding to stop pretending it's fine."

"I'm worried about causing drama at work."

"Same. That's part of why I think this should be small and private — not a workplace campaign or anything public. Just a few people who trust each other, being honest. Nobody needs to know about it who isn't part of it."

"Things aren't that bad." / "You're overreacting."

"Maybe. I hope so. But the research on democratic backsliding says the biggest danger is that each individual step seems small enough to ignore. That's how the window shifts. I'd rather do something now when it feels like an overreaction than do nothing and wish I had."

After the first conversation

Day
1–3
Send a brief follow-up. "Really glad we talked. Here's that site: youandafew.org" — this normalizes the conversation and signals you meant it.
Day
3–7
Have the second conversation with someone new. Use what you learned from the first one.
Week
2
Bring your first two or three people together. Over coffee, lunch, drinks — whatever feels natural. Let them meet each other. The group is now real.
Week
3+
Discuss the playbook together. What can your specific group do in your specific context? The youandafew.org site has a seven-step framework. Pick one step. Start there.
You and a Few

You're not starting a revolution.
You're having coffee.

And that's how every revolution starts. Print the brochure. Share it with someone. Have the conversation this week.

Download Brochure (PDF) View Print Version